IGF-1 Signaling Suppression Fails to Slow Aging in Mitochondrial Mutator Mice
IGF-1 signaling is perhaps the most well studied mechanism of aging, with extensive work predating the modern enthusiasm for treating aging as a medical condition. Investigation of IGF-1 signaling in the context of aging was a fellow traveler to investigations of calorie restriction in the context of aging, and while these are roads that lead to a greater understanding of the evolution of aging and how pace of aging adapts to environmental circumstances, and have given rise to classes of drugs that may modestly slow aging, they are not likely to lead to any meaningful class of rejuvenation therapy. From a purely scientific point of view, the incomplete state of understanding of cellular biochemistry means that there is a lot left to learn on the topic of how aging progresses and shifts in response to circumstances, and how different systems and mechanisms interact with one another. Surprises remain to be discovered, though once again it seems unlikely that any of the surprises relating to IGF-1 signaling will be capable of giving rise to meaningful rejuvenation therapies.
One strategy to elucidate the relationships between the hallmarks of aging is to investigate how the disruption of one hallmark affects the trajectory of another. In doing so, it may be possible to assess whether these processes act independently, synergistically, or in opposition of each other as they shape human life span. In addition, this strategy may reveal if a hierarchy exists between aging pathways, which could lead to a more integrated and causally ordered model of the aging process. In this study, we apply this strategy to investigate the relationship between two critical drivers of the aging process, mitochondrial mutagenesis and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) signaling.
A large body of evidence supports the idea that instability of the mitochondrial genome (i.e., changes in nucleotide sequence, copy number, and organization due to replication errors and DNA damage) leads to a progressive decline in mitochondrial function, which accelerates the natural aging process and contributes to a wide variety of age-related diseases, including sarcopenia, neurodegeneration, and heart failure. A similar body of work describes the role of IGF-1 signaling in the aging process. IGF-1 regulates the growth and metabolism of human tissues, and reduced IGF-1 signaling can not only extend mammalian life span but also confer resistance against various age-related diseases, including neurodegeneration, metabolic decline, and cardiovascular disease. However, how mitochondrial mutagenesis and IGF-1 signaling interact with each other to shape mammalian life span remains unclear.
Unexpectedly, we found that reduced IGF-1 signaling fails to extend the life span of mitochondrial mutator mice. Most of the longevity pathways that are normally initiated by IGF-1 suppression were either blocked or blunted in the mutator mice. These observations suggest that the prolongevity effects of IGF-1 suppression critically depend on the integrity of the mitochondrial genome, revealing an unexpected hierarchy in the pathways that control mammalian aging. Together, these findings deepen our understanding of the interactions between the hallmarks of aging and underscore the need for interventions that preserve the integrity of the mitochondrial genome.
This would appear to indicate that rejuvenation of the mitochondria should take precedence.
Probably, a short cut would be not to bother with rejuvenation of mitochondria but to identify and then cull the defective/aged ones, which must have biomarkers, and replace with new mitochondria. Which is what happens in nature already.
Bioreactors for production of mitochondria are essentially only a modification of bioreactors for production of stem cells, which is already done on a large scale.